The best pod around covers every mets related topic you’d want.

Hey Guys, Love the show! Been listening since it started with SNY! Would love for you guys to dive deeper into what makes Carson Benge so good and why you think he’ll be a good Major Leaguer? What under the hood or besides for his stats has you believing? Thanks! (Sorry if I submitted twice! Can’t tell if it went through).

Disappointed that my favorite Mets podcast landed with SNY….i don’t enjoy the content as much. I also dislike having less of Connor and Joe giving their opinions (as they spend more time interviewing guests)….

Choice A - Keep our young guys (Acuna, Ronny, Vientos and Baty )and bring up Sproat and/or McLean or Choice B trade one or more of them for a playoff dependable pitcher and a centerfielder?

This show is incredible and does a great job at looking at all areas and landscapes of Mets Land. The one issue is Connor constantly interrupts Joe. Let Joe cook.

I love the show but please end the game predicting what will happen in Met games during the coming week. It’s boring! Maybe year 1 it was OK but now it’s usually where I turn off because, who cares? And are you just promoting gambling like everyone else in MLB?

Since June, this team appears to lack urgency on several occasions and their energy seems to be zapped when a thing or two goes wrong during the game. A popular saying is “a hungry dog runs faster” and that seems to be true when lower performing teams play at or above the level of the Mets, especially those with substantially lower payrolls (Rays, Reds). Ownership has created a great environment especially with all the amenities to the players and their families, which begs the questions- are they too complacent? Are they too comfortable? Maybe a shake up with their perks needs to be changed or taken away to truly send a message.

I look forward to this podcast and really enjoy the Mets talk by Joe and Connor. It reminds me of typical conversations I used to have with my best friend who recently passed away. The “down on the farm” updates are particularly informative and give me great insight into our prospects. Keep up the great work.

So excited when the episode drops before my commute home. I haven’t heard much about Tylor lately. When is he coming back from the IL?

I check the stats every start, explain to me why Johah Tong isn’t up in AAA already?? -Dan from DC

Hey guys, just want to say this is the best baseball pod and an absolute must listen for Mets fans. It’s at the top of my podcast rotation every week as soon as new episodes drop! My question is: self scouting is paramount when dealing from your prospect pool (see Crow-Armstrong, Pete or Kelenic, Jared for both ends of the spectrum). Outside of Jett, Tong, McClean, and Peña, which prospects would you be most hesitant to include in a trade package? On the flip side of that, which of the more notable prospects would you be most willing to include to add a real piece? Thanks for the podcast, Joe and Conor!

Love the pod, always the best insight. With the trade deadline looming, which of our prospects could be defined as untouchable? Which prospects do we have the could be of interest to other teams?

Hey Guys - Just a quick follow up on our DeGrom conversation from last week. While I completely agree that the chances of Jake waiving the no-trade are slim to none, I have to disagree with your analysis of his performance. If you have a chance, take a second look at the stats. Some highlights: ERA: 2.12 WHIP: Under 1 AVG FASTBALL VELO: 97.1 Strikeouts down for sure. He otherwise still looks like a dominant ace to me. Ok, I’ll let it go now! Michael B

Love the pod! Have to note that this pod has Connor as the host and Joe as the analyst, where Badlands has Joe as the host and Connor as the analyst!! Anyways, my question is do you think Alvarez should be sent to AAA to help with his hitting and also what should the approach be to help Vientos regain his confidence??

Why can’t the Mets seem to develop any high leverage relievers from within their system? I guess Jose Bhutto is pretty good but he is the only reliever on the roster who was originally drafted or signed by the Mets. Every time we need an arm it’s time to call up an old retread like Devensky or Adcock or Genesis Cabrera. When was the last time a really good reliever came up through our system? Seth Lugo is 2016? I guess Bobby Parnell had 30 saves once. Jeurys Familia in 2012? Am I missing anyone? 4 guys in 13 years seems pretty bad. What do you attribute that to? Do they just try to make every decent arm a starter and then trade them before the experiment fails? Do they just fell why bother? It’s easier to just sign veterans?

I’ve listened to a bunch of different Mets podcasts and this one is the best. Connor and Joe are insightful, funny and always bring it with their down on the farm segment. And this is the year Connor takes the crown! New question: when is the right time to bring up a player like Jett? When the bats are slumping (like they are now) or just when the team is hitting but someone gets injured.l?

Enjoy the pod & have become a more regular listener. I heard every thing both of you said regarding Soto’s 2 obvious episodes “low energy” & I’m sure Mandi will address. But I attended the games agains the Nats in DC & have observed Soto on TV and he is not motivated & not displaying effort. He is last out of dugout at inning changes, minimal warm up, not really encouraging of team mates & not expecting Lindor or Nimo levels he needs he consistently display effort & support of team. I get settling in but he is a well paid veteran who has to sho it. Thoughts.

Lots of baseball podcasts out there. Very few are good enough to go beyond whining and complaining or playing armchair quarterback. This is one of only two that I actually appreciate and value for their genuine insight and appreciation for the game. And they actually know what’s going on in the minors and “under the hood” so I get to learn new info and context for what’s going on. Thanks fellas.

Maybe this is more of a psychology question than a baseball question, but why is the story every time a huge free agent comes here and struggles that they hate it here? It happened with Beltran and Lindor, but then they ended up thriving. Why are we all so quick to play armchair therapist with Mets top free agents when they arrive, and is our scrutiny just adding to a narrative that already insists upon itself to begin with?

There has been a lot of coverage of Lindor’s production from the lead off spot. There has been a lot of coverage of Nimmo’s new approach, and we can see that it isn’t working. What I don’t hear as a part of either story is that Nimmo was at his best when he was in the lead off spot and changed his approach when he was bumped for Lindor. Did the Mets ruin Nimmo?

Nimmo had a scare in the outfield against the D-Backs. If another outfielder goes down with an injury, is Drew Gilbert the next guy up? Or is there someone else in triple A they might use?

They do a great job breaking down the week to week of the Mets without the hyperbole of a lot of other shows. Awesome job at keeping us informed. Question: What’s the future look like for Colin Houck? I know he’s still super young but he’s a former 2-sport athlete and a top draft pick. He was #30 for the Mets coming into the season. Curious if we see him climbing or is it too soon to tell? Also curious because he developed into a Stud in my franchise on the Show. Love the podcast, keep it up!

Enjoy listening to the show every week! You guys are the best. Question for you two. Know Joe mentioned Cedric Mullins as a guy to possibly trade for last offseason before the Mets landed Siri. Mullins is, basically, the only bat raking for Baltimore through April. If the O’s continue to struggle, what do you think about the chances the Mets trade for him by the deadline?

Great Podcast that I look forward to each week. What are y’all thoughts on the complex Cohen plans to build around the stadium?

Hey Guys. Never miss a show. Love your friendly competition each week! At what point does the brain trust realize that Edwin is not the same guy. I can’t begin to describe the agita I get when the horns play. No lead is totally safe and with an ERA approaching 6, isn’t it time to make Stanek the go to?

Hey guys, love the pod! Is it just me, or is it time to break away from betting Nimmo 4th, or even 5th? It seems like it’s really changed his approach for the worst, making him an all or nothing guy, and perhaps moving him down to 7th can allow him to be a spark plug for the bottom of the lineup, and once he’s right, Mendy can move him back up in the order.

Awesome show love listening. Very suprised but loved hearing Connor talk football with bobbby as well. Do you guys think taking Nimmo out of lead off changed his approach for worse….

A wonderful podcast, with two intelligent and passionate hosts. Joe & Connor are genuinely sweet people, and they have created a safe haven for all Mets fans to freely discuss their favorite team. A comment & question on the 2025 team so far: Luisangel Acuna has proven to be a major league caliber player; he has elite speed, above average athleticism and defense, defensive versatility, & is able to put the ball in play consistently. He is absolutely the future 2B or CF of the Mets team. Thus far he has thoroughly outplayed Brett Baty, and is simply a more impactful player. Acuna is capable of being consistent a 2.0 WAR player, that can play Gold Glove Caliber defense & that can steal 30-40 bases at a minimum My question revolves around the Mets lineup configuration: With the offensive inconsistencies, that the Mets currently have so far; what would the ideal lineup be in your opinion, when McNeil & Alvarez return? Here’s mine: Lindor, Soto, Alonso, Winker, Vientos, Nimmo, Alvarez/Torrens, McNeil/Baty, & Acuna/Taylor Have a 4-6 of Vientos, Marte, & Nimmo, when Marte is the DH against lefties, and keep the rest of the lineup the same. What are your thoughts? Thank you & Much Love ❤️

Thank you guys for keeping us hard core Mets fan updated with the team specially with the farm system. Some people don’t realize how important is to grow talent from within! I have 2 questions: Are we concerned about Vientos slow start? Pete is protecting Soto but who’s going to protect Pete if not Vientos? Also: can you guys find out where Lindor got that sick multicolor gemstone Nuckles? Is so sick! LFGM!

The Mets-knowledge alone by these two without question puts this podcast above all. A must listen for all Mets fans! My question is, with Siri out for an unexpected period and Taylor’s troubles. Following a Jeff McNeil return, if Acuna continues to produce is there a world we see McNeil in LF again and Nimmo back in Center? It’s obvious the issues with the team right now aren’t so much defense related, but hitting and RISP. So do we prioritize bats with our pitchers success? Thank you guys, LFGM!

Hey guys, love the show, listen every week. Down on the farm question: Seems like recent draft pick Eli Serrano III is tearing the cover off the ball to start the year. Can you go over his background a bit and what your expectations are for him? Thanks for the pod!

Joe DeMayo and Conor Rogers are so knowledgeable about the sport and about the team, and above all, they are true Mets fans. You can feel their love for the team while learning a ton about it. Especially appreciate Joe’s knowledge of minor league baseball and his insights into the farm system.

Hi Guys. All of your accolades are well deserved. Never miss a show. While I would prefer Alcantara at the trade deadline because of team control, I think we can get Cease without sacrificing as many assets. If he proves a good fit, we should have the edge in free agency. Agree or disagree, or better option? Also, what are your career aspirations? Full time broadcasting for MLB team? Major league scouting/development, etc.? As always, keep up the great work! LGM! Joe

Hey guys, Alexander Canario really came on strong toward the end of camp with the two-homer, 5-RBI game against Miami on Sunday that opened some eyes. As the Opening Day roster is finalized, is there any way in your estimation that he can make the team? He definitely won’t pass through waivers and the Mets could always try to trade him and get something for him rather than let him walk, but he’s shown some real power that might play off the bench. Could Acuna possibly start in Triple A to accommodate Canario at least temporarily or does that leave the roster with not enough flexibility in the infield?

With the Nationals selling the naming rights to their stadium, it got me thinking about Citi Field. The 20yr partnership with Citi Bank is set to expire in 2029. If both sides are open to continuing, do you think Steve/Alex re-up? Or do you see them trying to bring in a new sponsor, especially with outside the stadium potentially being built up?

Love the show! Listen with my 8-year old son who is a die-hard Mets fan and we both wanted to give a shout out to Sean Reid-Foley for spending time with the fans this past Monday in Port St. Lucie - he was out there a long time signing stuff for the kids which was great to see. Would love to hear your thoughts on Sean and/or others who are the best candidates for surprise breakouts in the 2025 bullpen.

Does Frankie Montas injury make it more or less likely that the Mets trade Marte and Acuna in order to acquire another pitcher? Thanks for a great pod. I’m new listener and new fan. Got into the Mets because of my son and can’t get enough Mets content. Let’s go Mets! Tristan

Guys, given cost and fragility of starting pitchers, is anyone bucking conventional wisdom of “throw as hard as you can for as long as you can”? Ronnie and Smoltz and other experts long questioned the stats and theory leading to 5 inning starters. Not only old timers, but Verlander recently always saved velocity for later innings. Are any organizations revisiting conventions that don’t look so wise? if pitchers are told length isn’t valued, look what you get. kev from sarasota

Excellent pod, guys - a family favorite for us! One question for ya: I love the Polar Bear, but might he be overestimating the impact that his Qualifying Offer had on his market? Everything has a price, and front offices are sharp. Is the compensatory pick worth $5M? $10M? What impact do we think it had on what contract Pete would have gotten without the QO? At the start of all this, we would have expected him to get a longer, higher dollar deal than Christian Walker’s; did the QO really impact things that much? Thanks, as always.

Soto in the 3rd spot maximizes his protection effect. Alonso, Vientos, or Nimmo hitting before him would see better pitches, enhancing their performance. Batting Soto 2nd negates this strategic advantage. What do you think?

I really enjoy the way Connor and Joe go about dissecting the Mets farm system and off season plans. They work great together and I’m excited to hear their spring training coverage! Question: would a top prospect swap be out the question? It’s no secret the Mets currently have a surplus of solid infield prospects- is there a team out there that has a surplus of starting pitching prospects that could be a match? Thanks!

I’m relieved Pete is back there’s no question they’re a better team with him at 1st. But I am also concerned. Not about any lingering hard feelings about the contract negotiations, but about the pressure Pete may feel protecting Soto. If we get to May and teams are consistently pitching around or walking Soto to get to Pete because he’s not hitting, you can cue the boo birds and all the talking heads on the radio saying he’s not clutch and then it can all spiral from there. Am I right to be worried? Or do you think the home run against the Brewers slayed a lot of those demons for Pete and for Mets fans?

Top notch podcasting guys, thanks for keeping us in the loop with our beloved Mets. Question: Jeff McNeil has been much maligned by Mets fans over the past couple of years, but he’s one of my favorites. What are the upside and downside scenario’s with Jeff, and where do you think his season will truly land?

I know it’s far fetched but why are the Mets so opposed or not looking at giving Trevor bauer a league minimum for 1 year i know he brings baggage but he’s still above average and cheap to add depth.

Hey big fan of the pod. Question…how come no teams are showing interest in Jose Quintana this offseason? Proven vet and he was amazing down the stretch last year. I don’t think he’d cost all that much, what gives? Also, thoughts on bringing back Brooks Raley?

There’s been so much talk about if we don’t get Alonso, then we’ll move Mark Vientos to first and give Baty another go or find another option at third. I want to know why we’re entertaining this idea so much? To me it seems like Vientos has earned his spot at third base, at least for now, and the last thing we want to do is take a guy going into his sophomore season where he still has to prove it again a little bit and make him learn another position. That’s crazy! Shouldn’t this just be Baty’s second chance to find a spot on this team - this time at first base - and if it doesn’t work out then we look for another solution at first? Why are we moving Mark Vientos around to give Baty or some other question mark a shot at third. Let the guy build off a great rookie season and provide him with some stability at his position.

Hey all, love the show and enjoy all the discussion from the major league roster down to prospects in the DSL. Mailbag Question: what do you guys think the Mets ultimately do with Jose Butto? If he needs 2-3 days rest between bullpen outings then I feel like it’s not worth it to have him in the pen and he should just prepare to be starting pitcher depth (I have very little confidence in both Peterson and Montas).

Thank you guys so much for the outstanding work you do. Big fan of CR (shoutout to Badlands keeping me sane) and Joe. Question: With the signing of Tanner Scott, LA becomes more and more of a juggernaut, with seemingly boundless resources. After what seemed like a breeze to a WS title last year, LA has gotten even better. Is there any point at which Stearns may consider reevaluating his conservative free agent approach? How do the Mets get past LA when they are willing to give players contracts the Mets won’t? Thank you!

Great show! I have two questions: 1. Why would the Mets not want to give Starling Marte a real long look at DH? He seems like the type of player who benefits from consistent play (everyday or nearly everyday), but he is starting to show his age a little with the injuries. Slotting him in at DH would give him an opportunity to play everyday while saving his legs. He could occasionally spell Soto in right too. Now that Winker is on the team, I feel like Marte won’t get the look at DH that he deserves. Thoughts? Question 2: I’m going to be in St Lucie this spring for the first time ever. I’ve never been to a spring training game. Any recommendations about to do while I’m there. I’m naturally going to catch a game or two, but what else can/should a Mets fan do? I’m open to any recommendations. Places to eat? Things to see? What to do while in the area? Thanks guys, keep up the great show!

Hey guys, Love the show! If Pete signs with another team. do you think the Mets would go all in for Munetaka Murakami, if he gets posted next year? He is able to play both 3rd and 1st.