I love this I am 10 and this is the best podcast ever I need 2 episodes a week now (maybe 3) love it keep it going.

I love the stories, a mix of supernatural, lore, & high strangeness. The hosts are engaging and fun to listen to. I love Ashley too, but have zero problems with the slightly new format. I’m here for the stories & the banter. Keep it up! One of my all time favorite podcasts. ✨

Loved this pod when it was Ashely and still love it even more with Rasha and Yvette. Even my kids ask to listen to this podcast on the daily.

This was my favorite podcast when Ashley Flowers was telling the stories. It’s just not the same.

Its so make believe it’ll make you cringe. I really wanted to like this but I couldn’t…. Wouldn’t recommend

I started with Ashley and it was amazing. Unfortunately, now the sheer personality and the story telling isn't the same quality as Ashley. The two hosts digress and it's feels "so super-fake". Specially for the skeptical this show ends up being just another hoodwink. I tried for months, forced myself to listen, kept losing interest after 4 minutes in. Definitely not the same as with Ashley.

This has become my most listened to podcast lately. The stories pull me in and give me the creepiness I need in my life, and at the same time I really love the sweet sisterly bond between rasha and Yvette. Love hearing the mix of personal touches of their life mixed in with the scary. It definitely makes it feel more meaningful.

Some episodes are great. But some aren’t supernatural at all and are just episodes about lore, which of course aren’t believable at all, just silly stories. The Elvis story literally had me rolling my eyes and I turned it off. Hoping this turns back to more supernatural stories…

They cover stories I’ve always been fascinated with and others I never heard of. Coincidence or supernatural?! The hosts do a great job at analyzing various angels of the subject matter.

I listened to this podcast since I was seven! I’m still pretty young but I love the podcast! I miss Ashley but Rasha and Yvette are really good. I finished the whole podcast and I would like more conspiracy episodes than alien but I still love it all! Also I love how you connect the story’s to your mom and Hawaii. It makes the stories way more interesting and personal. More guests please!

Thomas Cranmer’s children died without issue. So no decedents

The new hosts are making episodes so difficult to listen to, I was really really excited to hear baba yaga but honestly these women read the script awfully and make the worst little comments between story telling. Please bring Ash back. :(

At first, I thought the new hosts are ok. I adore Ashley as the host and missed her. She catches my attention and holds it. As I continued to listen week to keep, I have grown to and look forward to listening to these wonderful women.

I’ve listened to this podcast since the very first episode and after this week I will no longer be listening. The two new girls were never as good as Ashley flowers but I gave them a chance. Now any time the story has to do with anything they make some connection to talk about their mom and that’s not what this show was about. Bring back Ashley

It just sounds like very scripted and unnatural. I like the subject matter and topics but I feel like they could have some more genuine relaxed conversation in the mix with the information.

First of all, the podcast was good when Ashley did every episode. Many reviews have say that the new hosts ruin the show, and I have to agree. I came here to listen to episodes with supernatural elements, and the show has devolved into personal anecdotes and it feels like the story is being ruined. I can’t stand the host’s voices, and having an entire episode dedicated to their personal lives? Seriously? Nobody asked for that! Second, what kind of weird and mentally ill conspiracy theory is being peddled here? I just checked the Wikipedia article for Elvis Presley, and it makes no mention of him having any supernatural powers like telekinesis, astral projection or being visited by aliens. And he is definitely not an alien from Jupiter’s ninth moon. That was a stupid thing that the first Men in Black film made up! Another issue I have is the episode on Atlantis. Those people did NOT exist, it was just something made up by Disney for their movie. If it had been real though, I think that Disney’s film would have been way closer to what you guys said it was. The crystals were their life force, NOT some kind of battery! I used to listen to the show three years ago, and had never heard of it until that point. Ashley was wonderful, and now it’s just a major disappointment. Bring her back. Another review on here suggested discontinuing the show. While I don’t agree, I will unsubscribe if this keeps getting worse.

The last straw for me was the guest episode. It was so bad I couldn’t even get through 5 minutes without turning these blabbering women off. I’m here to listen to stories. Do your job. not to mention their inability to go one episode without talking about HAWAII or their personal stories. They talk sooo… sloww… and it drives me up the walls crazy. They have ruined this gem of a podcast with their useless side topics and the giggles. This isn’t a cutesy funny comedy show. This is a special show that had a very specific feel to it that made it great. Now that it’s gone, so is the personality of the show that made it so good in the first place.

Who are these random girls.. Painful listen. Too many ads. Let Ashley do her job.

What a weird take on Elvis. He was a drug addict with trauma who groomed a teenager to be his wife. The broad ideas were too much on this one for me. Typically I like this show as a “turn off my brain” kind of entertainment. Couldn’t even finish that one.

Ewww how much the host love that gross guy

I used to really love this podcast, but the new hosts aren’t a good fit for it. I really tried to like the new podcast, but I just can’t get into it anymore. I struggle to even get through the episodes now and really only listen if I have nothing else to listen to. I tried to put on an episode for a roadtrip and my boyfriend asked me to turn it off, he used to like to listen to it on our trips. I know Ashley can’t be in 10 places at once, but if there’s some way to bring her back or have her write the scripts or something… anything… maybe the podcast could be saved.

Tried to like the new hosts and it’s not happening.

Update- last week was amazing when Ashely did the entire podcast. I feel like yall are going to take away Ashley’s 2 min intro so that we can’t compare them to her. I will just keep relistening to the old episodes. I realize they must be under a contract and yall are doing everything you can to make them work but it just ain’t working. Best wishes to everyone. It’s painful to listen to the sisters. I know they were probably told to speak slowly and enunciate each and every syllable- but they just are not good! I want to hear the stories so bad-and somehow push myself through some of the podcasts-but the hosts are just SO bad. Nor do I connect with them. They try to be relatable but they arent. Nor are they funny. They come off super awkward. The worst is teasing us with 2 mins of Ashley in the very beginning with her amazing voice and speed at which she talks- to then make us listen to those two. Some people just do it well and Ashley is the best. Please either bring in people as good as Ashley or let her do it!

This is one of my favorite podcasts. With that said I was applauded to hear the voice of my toxic former employer Franklin Becker. I’m not sure what it is an ad for but take it off. He is one of the worst chefs I’ve ever seen. Constantly yelling and putting people down while making terrible business decisions and messing up the menu. Most recently he left many people unemployed after closing one restaurant without warning and then requiring document checks for immigrants. No company should work with him let alone such a great podcast

I listen to a variety of podcasts and it’s always the supernatural ones that really bother me the most, the hosts pretend like these stories have merit and are not some made up fiction to cover up some heinous abuse or something explainable. This is one of those shows designed to take advantage of the audience of people who are easily fooled. I guess let the grift continue though, if you believe in nothing (legitimate) you’ll fall for anything…

My kids and I loved this podcast when Ashley Flowers narrated it. We’ve been through the series a couple times and were excited to see the show returning, until we listened to the new hosts. It’s not just me, my kids (ages 15, 13, 11) cannot stand this new format. The back and forth bantering, the personal stories and opinions, the unnecessary babble between the host is all just so exhausting. We can’t get through one episode and I don’t even try to listen anymore. Instead, we replay the old episodes. My opinion: ether completely discontinued the podcast, or return with just Ashley Flowers as it was before. Continuing this way is torture and destructive to the original podcast.

Bring back Ashley flowers, she is a really good host, the new hosts are ok, Ashley was just better

This is so me on this type of podcast and like it will find the right people to listen to this podcast.♥️♥️👋🙌😊

I LOVE your show and I have been listening for a while and I know a place that no one really talks about but there’s a lot of information on it if you really dig. Tennessee. From Cryptids, to the UFO blow-up in Williamson County in the 90’s, The Volunteer state is an undiscovered hotspot for supernatural occurrences! It would be amazing if you did an episode on the supernatural events of Tennessee.

I think the new hosts have gotten better, but I agree with other reviews that there are too many sidebars about their personal lives. We are here for the spooky stories, and I think that a more story-like way of sharing them is better than a conversational tone with a lot of personal anecdotes. Still love the show, but I think some small changes could help improve the listening experience!

Yvette and Rasha are great story tellers. They’re awesome. I look forward to each episode!

This show was great when Ashley had it and I was SO excited it was coming back… but the new girls are horrible and annoying, esp the older sounding one. I am so interested in these topics, but the hosts are horrible!! I can’t even listen and pay attention even if it is a story I am super interested in. What a letdown. And they giggle…constantly…about things that aren’t funny. I really want Ashley to take this one back. Ashley…if you read this, please save us from these hosts bc the stories are great, the people telling them are just awful!!!! Unsubscribing from this one til the hosts are changed or Ashley takes it back! Update… months later I decided to give this podcast another try as it is a topic I am interested in, and again I am even more blown away at how horrible these hosts are!! I couldn’t even get through the first 30 seconds! Also…. NO ONE CARES ABOUT ALL YOUR PERSONAL STORIES!!!!! JUST TALK ABOUT THE PODCAST TOPIC!!!

The new hosts seem super nice and lovely but I just don’t love the new show. I appreciate they love and miss their mom but a story about her is mentioned in every single episode. That plus stories about how they grew up etc etc etc …. I want to hear the spookiness and weird stuff.

I was obsessed with this podcast when it first came out. I absolutely love Ashley Flowers and the way she tells stories. I am not a fan of the new hosts. I have been listening to all of their episodes and they talk too much about their personal life. They bring up their mother in EVERY SINGLE EPISODE. I respect and understand that they love and miss their mom, but I would prefer for them to stay on topic and continue the story without side tracking constantly about themselves and their family. PLEASE BRING BACK ASHLEY!!!

Reads like a bad book report

I love this podcast!! I have been listening to Ashley and Britt for years and just found this. I love the sisters! Their voices are perfect for this show. So much fun. Thank you ladies.

Used to love this podcast when Ashley hosted it. New hosts aren’t enjoyable for me at all. Not great at storytelling, share too much of their personal lives that isn’t relevant, and CONSTANTLY shoehorn their family into conversations. We get that you love your family, but just tell the story. You can talk about your family when an audience isn’t listening. Unsubscribing.

Update: After giving the new show a fair shot, I've found the banter of the new host to be distracting whenever they delve into their personal life. I much prefer the earlier episodes, where Ashley delivered the stories directly, without all the back-and-forth. That approach created a creepy and intriguing vibe. Honestly, I'm not enjoying the conversations in this show; I tend to lose interest. Sorry, Ashley! This show was meant to be told by a single person.

not a fan of the style of the cranmer family demon episode. i find it hard to follow the story when the guests are *constantly* chiming in with tangentially related stories. not trying to be a hater, i really tried to make it through, but i found myself having to skip back to relisten to what the hosts said to find out what made the guest interrupt the story in the first place. no hate to the guests, but please do not do this again 😭

Bring Ashley back, her storytelling was way better and she doesn’t randomly interject with bad jokes.

I am always excited for the next episode and can’t wait to see what it’s about

I really love that Yvette and Russia brought something new to the show. They were funny. I really loved Ashley flowers and her perspective on things.

I love all of her podcasts but this one might be my favorite. Every episode is interesting. Please never stop doing them Edit: Have to change my review the pod was much better with Ashley. this team also has to always interject their bias’s in the story. Their bias political and cultural takes. Just tell the story

Love Yvette and Rasha! I am glad I found them after listening to their last podcast.

Ashley please take this podcast over. Adding a 3rd only made it worse

I was initially sad Ashley was not a bigger part of the podcast…BUT I’m glad I gave Yvette and Rasha a chance. I really love what they bring to the show! I love that the episodes have fresh topics, not just rehashing the same stories you hear on all supernatural type podcasts. I’ve listened to all their episodes in like a month!

Really fun at the beginning but where is Ashley

Really loving this show and look forward to new episodes. I feel like the new hosts have really found their groove.

Ashley Flowers is the right one for the job please bring her back

Unfortunately the new hosts aren’t great at storytelling. I’ve tried giving them several chances and it seems each week it just gets worse and sometimes I just have to turn it off mid-episode. I was SO excited to have this show brought back, but it’s become almost insufferable.