Rotten mango is my go to pod for true crime, they get all the facts and do their best to not stray too far from the most important part-the victims getting justice. Also a lot of people critique when she censors certain words but she does that because these are also posted on YouTube and will get taken down otherwise.

i love her podcast because she respects the victims and also respects the true facts without having a bias against anyone. She is my first podcast and the only one i listen to. i really love all of your hardwork and shout out to your team too for giving light to a case!

I love Stephanie’s podcast, It’s very informational about what goes on around the world and how people can be cruel and evil and show people’s true colors and people sympathy.

Don’t get me wrong, I love Stephanie! It’s very clear she does her research, and thinks things through, BUT. Her videos about Karen Read or Diddy are repetitive and it’s getting tiring. :< I would like more diverse cases. I don’t understand why people are complaining about the use of “netizen” though. She is actually the only podcast I listen to though! <3

If they would stop the censoring, this would be a fantastic podcast. If you are not mature enough to hear or say the real words for “SA” or “self exit”, you should not be in the true crime genre.

I love rotten mango,but the constant 2-3 part cases are getting out of hand the cases are coming more well known and they seem more like mysterys than true crime (but what do i know) so in my opinion if you like reptive cases this is for you.

I have LOVED this podcast for a very long time. I have listened to every single episode. I understand that she likes to cover big cases but I’m so sick of hearing about diddy and Karen reed. I would normally just skip the episode but she had literally ONLY posted diddy stuff for several weeks then now that the diddy thing is over she is making episode after episode of Karen reed! No other cases thrown in just week after week the same thing. I have to find another podcast like this one but I don’t think anyone can beat Stephanie on her story telling abilities. If you like to hear about Diddy and Karen Reed till the end of time this is the podcast for you!

She gets facts wrong CONSTANTLY. You can tell she doesn’t do any research and just reads off whatever her writers give her. Also she’s annoying lol

This podcast is lovely! The use of netizens is well placed, as you HAVE to say it for people who are not legally working on the case, instead of just “people”. The Sean Combs coverage is well versed, along with a bit of humor so it’s not completely boring.

cases are so indepth and well researched, some times names are hard to follow though— which depending on the case can be REALLY annoying

I’ve been listening to this podcast for over two years and I still love the way she explains every case and makes sure to include cultural dynamics. I definitely recommend listening to this, as it is the only true crime podcast I can listen to without getting bored. Despite all the complaints over diddy coverage, it is pretty easy to avoid listening to those episodes, so I don’t see what the problem is.

I started listening to this podcast and I’m in love with it!

Awesome podcast! Some suggestions: PLEASE put the names of the victims and perpetrators first. I get lost many times and need to go to the transcript to find the names. The series episodes are exhausting and are more like fillers.

My favorite podcast to listen to when cleaning or doing any other daily activities

I like the show but I can’t binge it like I like to do with other shows because she says netizen probably 50 times or more each episode. Just say people or something similar so you’re not saying it so much. Also she gets way too theatrical sometimes which is annoying but I do like most cases she covers other than Diddy.

I love this podcast SO much and listen to it a lot and I think this podcast is definitely my favorite

I know that some people are complaining about the diddy coverage but I think it’s amazing! I wanna hear every detail you spend hours in court for.

SO GREAT!! Covers topics very well and in detail. You should totally do a collab with Kendall Rae

loved your podcast from the start!

don’t crash out bc of the diddy trial come back

I love this podcast so much! its so different from other true crime podcasts and it’s truly my favorite but i have been skipping your episodes lately because of all the p diddy coverage. please!!! we want something other than p diddy

So far this podcast is awesome !!! Really enjoy it the story’s are so sad tho :(

I love this podcast so much! The format is awesome and you stay neutral while still expressing your opinion! I really appreciate how you don’t sugarcoat a lot of cases but still find ways to keep the content cleaner than some podcasts! Overall great podcast! Love what you’re doing girl keep it up!

this podcast got me into true crime love it. ❤️ Edit but please no more diddy I would love to see more cults but no pressure

You’re making me listen to crime junkies again. That’s not a good thing! We’ve beat the Diddy case with a stick, can we PLEASE get different content that’s asked for.

Rotten Mango is my comfort podcast. I always come back to it because I love the format. Mr. Rotten Mango is the perfect audience because he reacts and asks the questions the way I want to. Keep up the good work. Amazing that you got to actually sit in on such a huge trial

Love the show! But I’m wondering, why edit out words like “ecstasy, porn, etc” are you not allowed to put it on the podcast or what? I thought the whole reason behind podcasting is that you can speak freely. No?

usually i can’t listen to content related to things like diddy/ epstein but i realized it’s because the coverage is too “objective” and not in support of victims. i have been SAT for your coverage of the trial. stay safe !!

at this point i listen to this anytime i dont have to listen to someone talk, this is an AMAZING podcast😭❤️

Pls stop with Diddy it is starting to make the pod less engage

ii love mangos but ii dont like them rotten... THIS CHANGED MY MIND

mango youre so so engaging, but olease stop with diddyyyyy. I havent listened to you in MONTHS only because you keep covering diddys case over and over and OVER again 😭 pls do some other cases

GUUUURL. Do you really not know that “can’t stop, won’t stop” is basically synonymous with P. Diddy? It’s like his unofficial tagline—he dropped it in almost every track he inserted himself on in the ’90s. It’s classic Diddy. I adore you and your podcast, but I was cringing (with love!) when you all guessed the phrase might’ve come from Kid Cudi. 😩 Cudi was clearly poking fun at Diddy when he repeated the line—like 20 times—and that was nearly two decades after Diddy made it famous. Just had to look out and clue you in—because halfway through laughing, I realized it’s probably just my age showing. Not laughing at you, just at the moment. Gotta love a good generational gap! Still love the show. 💛

I honestly love rotten mango but the weeks long focus on diddy is obnoxious. everyone is covering diddy. it’s tiresome. bring back murder.

😏

i enjoyed

I love Stephanie and her husbands views on these stories! They are so soothing to listen to and tell the stories in the best kind of way!

Rotten Mango is hands-down one of the best true crime podcasts out there. The research is deep, the storytelling is intentional, and the production quality is chef’s kiss. To those complaining about specific episodes (like the Diddy trial)—this is a review for the podcast, not your personal discomfort. If a topic’s not for you, here’s a tip: click next. Don’t tank the ratings because you can’t handle nuance. Stephanie and the team deliver every time. Period. Stephanie, you’re a baddie.

Keep doing what you’re doing. Someone mentioned you, on my other podcast and I hope they’re wrong about, “ I know you “ ;comment .

There are like more cases out there that are WAY MORE interesting than Oh P Diddy. Like alot of people me included are sooo tired 😭. Just cover something else PLEASE People are asking you to stop or atleast give us more interesting Cases

frequently, the female host speaks using a fake stereotypical latinx accent. it’s offensive and needs to stop.

Her show was really good when it was about unknown murder crimes. Now She obsessed with the Diddy case which can be watched or listened to almost anywhere.

Stephanie and ENTIRE team! You guys are the GOAT !!! I appreciate your hard work with ALL of the episodes BUT the Diddy trail yall outdid yourself! I appreciate your dedication and commitment to this case! You have taken us into that court room ! Thank you all!!!! Luv you ALL

This has become my fav podcast. I started by listening to coverage of the Diddy trial. The host is phenomenal at giving details of what went on in the court.

I was already bored of all the Diddy coverage before the trial and before she and everyone else even started covering it but now that’s all this podcast has turned into. Not even worth being subscribed to it anymore. Break up the content or make a different channel. It’s not good content. It’s just sensationalized media.

Queen I love you but I don’t care about diddy. Nobody does. We want something else, I’ve started to listen to you 2020 podcasts because they aren’t all about diddy. I’m so sorry but we’re tired :[

Stephanie seems to have an excellent team that provides her a great deal of information and insight into the cases she reviews, but the Diddy case is grossly reported I couldn’t bear to listen past episode 2. The inflections in Stephanie’s voice as she “re-enacts” are not only unbearably unpleasant to listen to but undeniably overly dramatized. Very disappointed that this another typical podcast that isn’t respectful towards the victims/story but for the sensationalism of it.

I really like the podcast and the stories that go with it, but I don’t like the dramatic way in which Stephanie relays info. It gets to be more theatrical, instead of informational. I’ve been listening to the Diddy trial, and the way she relays the witness testimony drives me bananas.

Stephanie is so sweet and so respectful of the families and the victims she puts actual care in these episodes

This is my favorite podcast. I used to listen to crime junkie but then my friend told me about rotten mango and I just immediately fell in love. The way Stephanie tells the stories amazes me. She even inspired me to start my own podcast (still working on it). I love that she is supporting so many causes and her recent story about the girl with DID helped me portray DID in the book I am working on. I listen to this podcast whenever I am in the park or in my free time. I just adore this. And one more thing to the people who hate on this podcast, her voice is not annoying and her story telling is great, and cases are very sensitive so changing victim names, and the way certain words are said like SA is perfectly fine. Keep up the good work Stephanie. 😁🤩