Love how detailed Mary Paine is. I enjoy her podcasts a whole lot. Also enjoy very much the smoothness of each of the episodes with Kimberly, Keysha, Katy and Amye. II always look forward to hearing any of the podcasts from Pink Shade; they always cover my favorite shows. Thank you for giving me laughs and keep up the great job.

The best coverage of our favorite TLC Shows. MP is the smartest, quickest and best commentator for these nightmare people, especially the 90 days morons. MP, Keisha and Kimberly have beautiful, smooth and sexy necks! And go-go great southern speech imitations

Yes MP you have a lot of Jehovah’s Witness listeners. Encouraging people and sharing scriptures is our ministry. We meet thousands of people who appreciate someone coming to give of themselves freely. It was nice of you to talk with the elderly women and perhaps they missed your cue for them to leave. We don’t disparage other religions, or uninterested people. We do this out of love. I enjoy hearing your point of view on Bravo topics. You are hilarious and I hope your podcast continues to thrive.

Love you guys. And don’t listen to that supposed brown person, w username greypearl. She doesn’t know what TF she’s talking about. Nobody likes coconuts 🥥

I absolutely love MP and Kimberly’s chemistry. I started being a fan of K’s back at the beginning of Date with Dateline like 10 years ago. That’s how I found out about Pink Shade and now I’m a listener forever! Kimberly, you are my spirit animal! From fear of heights, need for SSRIs, absolute despise for Coltie and Jovon, and incels in general, being a girl’s girl and wanting to save them all from awful, awful men… I can go on forever! Listening to you makes my day!! Katie is a wonderful human but it feels like you have to tone yourself waaaay down in Date. And with MP and Matt you just let it rip and it’s beyond amazing!

Love this podcast and the guests. Kimberly being my favorite guest. Love her humor! Mary Payne you are always great. Especially enjoy the “filth” coming from bunker takeovers.

…tops. Good job!

Not smart.

Mary Payne is someone I would want to be best friends with. Her and her friends that she podcast with are hilarious! And Thank you for calling out the Plath family for who they really are. A bunch of Bozos.

This podcast never fails to make me laugh. I love all her TLC content and they always share my opinions! 10/10 would recommend!!

Love the hosts, everyone is so funny!

Margo is rude, out of place and she’s obnoxious. ALL the trouble that Emma and her beautiful staff went to for the group to enjoy every minute, was really brought down by Margo’s ignorant behavior. Imagine being invited to such an incredible event and being obnoxious. Zero etiquette for sure.

I just came across this podcast after I started watching Welcome to Plathville. I only just dove in to the current season after watching a a few episodes when it came out. Now I’m watching just because of these recaps and was delighted to learn that Kimberly from a date with dateline is a guest! Spot on and very funny analysis

I enjoy every episode with Kimberly!!

Mary Payne and all her crew are the best. It’s if you know you just know. She knows. Ingrid, Kimberly, collabs with Matt and Poodle will entertain and delight. She keeps it real.

Hey Lady’s .. because of yall I had to watch Temptation Island..Jack looks just like a Monchichi .. that’s a 80 toy google it… the way yall discussed his look is a chefs kiss.. keep it up Kitty❣️

Both the old episodes and current season, you guys are always the best with the plaths! Stay on their necks. Them and Forrest’s mom. Great recaps!

Many laugh out loud moments! Love this show

Mary Payne & team are amazing! They are always on point with their opinions. I love that they don’t make excuses for terrible people (like the Plaths) and tell it like it is. I love this podcast and I subscribe to the Patreon. There’s always a ton of content! Pink Shade it one of my top favorite podcasts hands down!

I love the way that they call people out for being terrible. Keep it up, ladies.

New Plathville coverage is the best!!

I love this podcast. Thank you MP and Kimberly for calling out the Plath family for their bad behavior and terrible morals. Anyone who has an issue with this may need to take a long look in the mirror.

We realize you have to make money, but the amount of commercials in this pd are really getting too overwhelming-

Love these ladies! They are so funny and relatable! Can't stop listening, laughing and smiling!

Loved every minute of it , you two ‼️‼️

Pink Shade is my favorite podcast. All of you Negative Nellies of late move on to something else. I enjoy hearing about her life from her recent health scare to her trips to even her fruit fly invasion. As John Wayne said to Barbara Walters after her 1st World News program with Harry Reasoner, “Don’t let the bas…ards get you down!” Keep up the good work and never stop podcasting….please! Edit update…really enjoyed the interview with Elise.

I love episodes w Kimberly

So funny

Mary Payne is so fun and always makes me smile and usually LOL.

Truth tellers about the Socioplathes!!

So enjoy this podcast ! Love Mary Payne and Kimberly! I laugh so hard at Mary Paynes impression of Lisa from BT 90 😂, hilarious !! Great interview with Elise from Single Life !! Appreciate everyone’s hard work 💕💕

Love to listen to pink shade. Keep doing what you do! Go in on everyone on all of the shows please! Don’t ever stop. It cracks me up!

These ladies are hilarious and honest! If you can’t handle facts, don’t listen.

You guys are making me feel so validated with ur plathville cover 😭

Love this podcast and look forward to the weekly recap of Plathville. Thank for making me laugh- love all you do!

Love everything they cover especially PLATHVILLE!! I always agree with their takes

I am really enjoying Kimberly’s snark on this season. And of course love Mary Payne’s take on all of this.

You and your cohosts are the BEST: Relatable, funny, down-to-Earth, informative, and entertaining.

I’d give 10 stars if I could. I love listening to MP and Kimberly so much! I can’t afford Patreon, but I live for the free feed drops! Sooooo thankful that Plathville is available to us freeloaders lol.

Love the topics, love the guests and love Mary Payne! Great podcast for anyone who follows trashy reality TV and pop culture.

MP is the hardest working woman in the biz!

Absolutely love MP, Keisha, and Kimberly. The witty banter about our favorite trashy shows makes any commute a million times better.

This show rocks! I started out listening to just LALU but now I’m a member. Love Mary Payne and all her guest hosts!

We’re best friends and she doesn’t even know it. Love all the content.

Ladies you do you! Love the content and I always look forward to listening!

Updated 2026: plaths are grosssssss!!! MPG is rolling out content at lightning speed (appropriate, right?) I watch terrible TV shows just so I can follow everything these ladies snark on.

I look forward to your review of Plathville and agree with your opinions. It’s so much fun to listen.

This is my favorite podcast! MP & Kimberly absolutely crack me up 😂 TLC Tuesday is my favorite day of the week :)

So funny and correct ! Calling out all the BS ! Love both co hosts !

Love love love Mary Payne! Always find myself laughing out loud to every episode! I wish she could give a walking recap/voiceover of life for me! 😂 Especially love the Keisha collabs! Chef’s kiss!