You guys are a true crime podcast. Please stick to true crime. We don’t want to hear your obvious hate towards a certain political side. If we did we’d just tune into the news.

Started listening during the shutdown. These women started the true crime obsession for me and they are still crushing it. Keep going, Karen & Georgia! You two tell stories that we care about, make us laugh, and illuminate other awesome voices in our culture that enrich our lives! Thank you!

What can I say that hasn’t already been said? You both mean so much to me—you’ve been there for me in ways you could never imagine. Your continued use of your platform to stand up for injustices is inspiring. I feel so truly connected with you both. I cried when Georgia bought her first home. I sobbed when Elvis died. I’ve followed so many of your recommendations. In this weird way, you two have shaped me as a person. You will never be able to tangibly understand everything you’ve given me, nor are there words to describe it, but I love you both and you’ve made me a better, more conscious person. Thank you for all you have done and all you will do in the future my dearest of friends.

Folie à deux… wait, what kind of sisters? I’ve hear the dog-whistle before on the show before…but listening today made me realize it is time to move on. Good luck “ladies”.

I absolutely LOVE their comedy and storytelling! I don’t love the political views, but I understand everyone has the right to their own opinions and viewpoints. We sometimes have to agree to disagree and that’s okay. They are a wonderful, funny, thoughtful and entertaining team and I enjoy listening to them. The only time I am a skipper is during the long-winded political conversations.

I have loved this podcast for 7 years. So funny and listening feels like old friends. For everyone leaving negative reviews maybe calm down and just go try another podcast. I don’t agree with everything they say either, but that’s life. These reviewers are too sensitive.

Karen and Georgia are the same funny, POLITICAL, empathetic women they have always been. The people whining about them being too liberal or they need to stop talking about politics have let themselves get caught up in a cult. They were never fans of this podcast if they’re crying about it NOW.

I stopped listening about 2-3 years ago. The politics, liberalism, and lies just made the entire show hard to listen to. I used to love the show, but when all they do is bash anyone who doesn’t believe the way they do, I’d rather listen to true crime than to two bitter, sad women. I actually looked at reviews to see if they had changed their tactics, but it appears they’ve not read their own reviews.

This podcast is filled with political lies and the podcasters limited views. Stick to the story

I loved them from the beginning. Now I have to say goodbye. All the politics, anger and false narratives. Ugh! What a bummer! I’m also a Sonoma county girl. So so disappointed.

All the stars: I started listening during their 2nd or 3rd year when I discovered them. 1) I have laughed so hard I hearted certain episodes to go back and laugh again. I have made my bed while listening, shocked, that they were talking about the grandfather of my colleague 😳. I H w cried at when they’ve shared vulnerable life events. God bless these two. I hope to see them in person one day (pls come to ND - I know that’s a big ask).

Still putting out false propaganda… the show should be an outlet but apparently putting out false narratives and hate is all you can do. Name one thing that has been taken from you and your gated community lives…

I have been listening for years and took a break since I only listen while at work and didn’t have that option for a while. But I enjoy your storytelling so much and the banter is the best and my favorite part!

Funniest true crime podcast that exists. These ladies never fail to make me laugh. Will never stop listening.

I absolutely love the rewind episodes, but producers, can you PLEASE have Karen and Georgia relisten to their old intros before recording, at the very least? It’s so obvious that they are not, and it feels like such a miss. They are so apologetic about who they were or what they said, when it’s those flawed humans that we originally fell in love with!

I’ve learned so much listening to these ladies.it makes my drives to and from work so much more interesting. It’s like getting together with friends every day.

Love this podcast!! These ladies are smart, hilarious, and relatable! My sister and I are hoping this new tour goes great because we have been waiting since before Covid to come to a show. Fingers crossed for future shows and hopeful you ladies make it anywhere close to Nashville or Atlanta because we will be there!! ( maybe if we are really lucky you do both in the future and we can double up!) Love you ladies and wish you nothing but the best! SSDGM- Michelle

Used to love them. Went so liberal and really started throwing politics down everyone’s throat. Not to mention a chunk of what they say is just flat out wrong. Bye ladies.

Long time listener first time reviewer because I couldn’t find an unused nickname. Anyway, this podcast is the perfect mix of funny and murdery. Love these ladies!

Day… something listener? I’ve been listening and thanking you for years. Thank you ❤️

Completely unhinged but completely successful.😂👍 Long time listener, I admire you’re ability to be totally nuts but to also to be very successful. Sending love from New Bedford, Massachusetts and from the gator lands of Tampa, Fl. I aspire to be free like you guys are.

Too much off subject small talk. Not interested in listening to the two of you chat. It takes up more time than the actual subject matter.

These women are idiots. Imagine having a loved one murdered and then have a pair of moronic women call the heinous act their “favorite murder” ? Beyond clueless and insensitive.

They talk too much politics! Stop!!!

LOVE. THE. POD. I am soooo obsessed with the minisodes. THANK YOU SO MUCH

Year 1 listener ❤️ sink holes, politeness, post office farts, blows to the head and tampon suitcasin’ has never been the same since. Ps episode 444 with the reconstituted grandma ..🧑‍🍳😘

The Honda ads rival Snoop Dogg’s capacity to sell out. You can’t talk about the 90s and riot grrrl in one breath and “honking hoorays” in another. It’s actually painful to hear them. Sorry, but how much money do you need? Just an infinite amount, forever? This is why people believe Los Angeles has no soul.

I started listening from the 1st episode a few months ago. It’s entertaining but one of the hosts is just so dumb. Like 4th grade dropout dumb. It’s hard to listen to her sometimes. Fortunately, the other host is funny & interesting enough to keep me coming back for more murders.

I used to love this podcast, it was the first i was really addicted to. But the political left wing insanity is just more than i can deal with anymore. They were always a bit disrespectful of their listeners who didn’t share their political opinions, but it was bearable. No longer. They are hysterical lunatics now. ( and yes,i picked that especially to piss them off)

These two show no respect for victims and their families. Their idea of “humor” is pretty horrifying.

Love the show ladies! Nothing to complain here, but for all of the episodes to date, can there be someone in charge to filter them? It would be so much easier to navigate through all of the content instead of doomscrolling to find that one episode. Just a thought.

Yes! We’re back to horrible murders! Keep it up.

I’m crying! So exited to meet my podcast BFF’s!!

I’m a day one listener. I love and will always love this podcast. The intro banter even! Sometimes it’s the best part! But I feel like since they started videoing the episodes it’s not at relaxed. Maybe too concerned about the camera more versus it’s true authentic attitude, jokes and laughter. It has also moved away from murder to other stories, which I do appreciate sometimes, but it’s a true crime podcast for a reason. That aside, K &G are still the ones I look forward to hearing every week! That will never end. But listen to the rewinds, and you’ll know what I mean.

Thank you for speaking up talking about the ICE raids. It’s a sad time right now. We need love and kindness . Stop the hate.

Year one listener here. I’ve witnessed and experienced tremendous growth with the podcast and within myself at the same time. It’s been an amazing journey and I’m here for it every step of the way.

tehehehehe, kicking my feet and giggling w my parasocial besties

My oldest daughter told me about My Favorite Murder podcast last year 2024 and I’ve listened and loved it ever since. I listen to each episode when they come out and laugh when listening at work which makes the day sail by faster and of course the stories are interesting and informative coming from Karen and Georgia’s research and perspectives. Thank you for your podcasts and keep the laughter (and the cursing which makes me laugh) coming. I know murder isn’t a funny thing at all, but you both keep it light and interesting. JGM

Like bffs I’ve never met!

When I’m spiraling? Karen & Georgia. Need a laugh? Karen & Georgia. A smile? Karen & Georgia. Feeling good and want to keep it going? Karen & Georgia. You two have changed so many lives, and are seriously better than any/all anti depressants I’ve ever taken. I love your open, kind, vulnerable and very real vibes. Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Keep up the great hard work.

I vote for Karen or Georgia to cover the 1907 Tiflis bank robbery. Stalin and Lenin orchestrated bank robberies (in which Stalin threw boom booms) to fund the Bolshevik Revolution. A very inspiring revolutionary story for these times. The Bolshevik revolution enabled Lenin to outlaw antisemitism in the Soviet Union after all and put an end to the oppression of Tsarist Russia…just saying.

I finally realized how attached I am to Georgia&Karen when my significant other: 1. brought them up without my prompting the past weekend and 2. knew both of them by name. #hooked

I’ve loved My Favorite Murder for a long time, but I’ve never been more proud to be a fan than I am right now. Karen and Georgia are using their platform to speak up for families being torn apart—families who don’t have the safety or privilege many of us take for granted. This isn’t about politics. It’s about humanity. Seeing people leave one-star reviews because of that? Honestly heartbreaking. If standing up for others makes you mad… you’re in a cult. Call your dad. To Karen and Georgia—thank you for staying loud, hilarious, and unapologetically compassionate. You remind us what real advocacy looks like. Stay sexy, and don’t get murdered.

I’ve listened to MFM for years. I can no longer listen to their uninformed opinions and chatter. Perhaps get back to what the fans want???

I’ve been listening to mfm since 2018 and I still love it to this day!! The best podcast ever. Karen and Georgia are so much apart of my day to day conversations that my family and friends know them on a first name basis as well!!

Your comment about ICE agent kidnapping illegal aliens off the street. These people are criminals. They knew they were entering this and by you making the comments that they kidnapping these people is absolutely absurd. My parents are both immigrants. They came here and the hoops that they had to jump through to become legal citizens of this country was unimaginable, but you feel that just because people marched across the border, breaking our laws using our resources and raising our taxes that that’s OK. I have deleted you from my feed you were talking politics on a murder show about criminals. This is absolutely disgusting. I feel that everyone that is a fan of your podcast. Should never follow you again. You were off my feed. Politics has no place on your podcast and I have a feeling there’s gonna be repercussions for your political ideologies. Goodbye I will never listen again.

Love this podcast!!! I typically listen multiple times a week, but it feels like they have started covering more general disaster events and plane crashes/hijackings. The episodes go into so much technical detail I find myself tuning out or dropping off. While I usually enjoy tan occasional disaster one-off, it feels like they are becoming more and more frequent. I’m missing the OG true crime content that brought me to the podcast in the first place.

Found out about this pod last week. Started listening & am loving every second. I'm only on #11, but I hope it stays just as awesome as when I get to the 400s.

Been here since around 2018, read your first book in a week (FAST for me) and would absolutely love to read your next one!! Really really hope you’re not kidding 💗 would love to hear your updates, anything you left out the first time and to how your life changed from when you started your podcast until now

Too much extra. I wanted just a story and got too much small talk and politics. It was most of the episode.