The podcast is very good. It’s informative and gets me thinking outside of my usual box regarding some cards and decks. I hate to be one of those people, but on many occasions I almost skip the episode because of Richard. I listen to their Commander center sister show and it became a 5/5 once Richard left. He just comes off so negative and full of himself. It’s a very good podcast with a very glaring issue.

It is a good show overall, lots of relevant up to date news. Crim and Seth both seem very down for creative solutions for the game and trying new things. The reason I unsubscribed is the constant negative attitudes from Richard have killed me listening. Every card is either terrible or broken, he spends more time talking about his love for One Piece than anything positive or exciting for Magic. I’m all for fair criticism, Magic is far from perfect, but Richard doesn’t still seem to like the game in the slightest. I don’t know why he’s on the podcast. It’s very hard to enjoy when he constantly takes over to complain, talks over his cohosts and tells them they’re wrong, while also regularly being wrong himself.

I’m much more of a casual Magic player back from the olden days (Revised). I like to keep up to date with what’s happening and this is a low maintenance way to do so while being entertained. Crim, you are the man! I love control decks and there is nothing better than you talking about them on the show and in your videos. Keep up the great work gang 💪💪💪

Been playing magic for 7 yrs (I’m 14) and i love this podcast. Unrelated magics state right now is kind of worrying amirite?

Richard is a burned out boomer with a bias so strong towards Modern that his hot takes are predictable and not helpful, they’re distracting and take away from input of people in touch with the community and state of the game (Seth & Crim). Most of the time he’s sitting in “negative” cruise control, which requires zero consideration or thought. If he wasn’t the owner of the platform, they’d 86 this old man yelling at clouds.

If you dont like the show then just stop listening, don't be mean to people who put a lot of time and effort into making a podcast for people to enjoy. If you have nasty opinions, keep them to yourself! To mtggoldfish: I love your show and all of the comedy and fun conversations you have, cant wait for more episodes!

The content is great and the podcast as a whole is informative, wholesome, etc. One thing though..the host, Seth, does this weird podcast/stream voice that is very hard to listen to. 4 pitch changes in his voice in a single sentence like a 2am infomercial. Trying WAY too hard to “sound” like a podcaster - and I don’t think it’s his legitimate way of speaking. Just speak normally and professionally and the podcast comes away in a much better place.

The hosts laugh and cheerlead the exit of players with deep connections to the game in favor of new players that won’t stick around. And they do this because they have pathetic obsessions with IPs that have been run into the ground and are garbage. I hope mtg goldfish and universes beyond fail.

He genuinely makes this podcast unbearable. Unbelievable unaware

As board gamer one must sleeve their cards. It’s 2024 we aren’t Barbarians

And they're not leftists

I started playing a long time ago(Ice Age/Tempest-ish) and was a dumb little kid so i never really knew much about different formats and was more just collecting cards and playing with my friends who didn’t know any more. Then I come back to the game many years later and it’s pretty intimidating to show up to an LGS and try to play with so many more cards, formats, etc. This podcast has been great in helping me learn about basic stuff, like I didn’t even know what Standard or Modern even meant, so to hear about it being talked about gives me helpful context to not feel so out of the loop. Thanks guys, I really enjoy you all.

I really enjoy this podcast. It feels like sitting down after FNM with my friends and having a rounded conversation about the game as a whole. This show is great way to stay up to date on the happenings of MTG while listening to your favorite content creators have a relaxed discussion.

These guys have really lost their way. I have been listening to them for years and the podcast is truly meant for a small circle of Magic players. Shorthand names, off topic conversation, and random arguments about combos that are never explained are so common place that if you are new to Magic or a casual player this podcast will not help you. Not only do they not inform or explain well, but they also spend countless hours gabbing about the “politics” of Magic. Currently they have been talking over and around each other about some online feedback about Mark Rosewater, have not even started talking about Magic yet… I think players like the members of this podcast (the German guy excluded but they got rid of him) are helping to spread a toxic mentality within this game itself. 10/10 would NOT recommend!

Please fix your audio. There are bangs in the background, tapping, and other odd noises that could easily be reduced or eliminated.

It’s a good mix of thoughtful opinions that all take mtg exactly the right amount of seriously.

You guys are awesome and keep up good work. Always current and I love the website too.

TBH I’m a casual magic player but the crew at MTG Goldfish always make my passion for it peak. The podcast is awesome the YouTube is awesome, K don’t even play commander but the Commander Clash channel is incredible. I do wish they focused a bit less on competitive and more on just fun builds like I used to play when young but I fully understand. Absolutely great stuff that I wouldn’t change a minute of.

Great show and rly love everyone they always have a interesting opinion and great cards my only complaint is that they never read my fishmail richard if u read this my question is what is the first magic card you think of at the top of mind

These three guys are always fun to listen to. They laugh a lot and make everything about magic fun! Always a highlight of my week. A must listen if you like MTG.

PLEASE PLEASE MAKE BRANDON SANDERSON WRITE THE MTG LORE!!! His books are incredible and it would be so amazing to read magic lore. For Christmas I asked for some of his books and some mtg cards so if I could combine my two favorite hobbies, I would flip out!

True

I really like that you guys summarize the news because I’m not on social media every minute of the week, so I tend to get my digest from you.

The website is great for decks, and the podcast is great for info. Pretty much my go to for general Mtg content.

Crims great, seths great, and Richard is great. One of my favorite mtg podcasts!

Horrible almost every episode. Pessimistic, horrible opinions. Honestly don’t know why they play the game or have a podcast. Crims alright tho

Crim (TheAsianAvenger), Seth (SaffronOlive) and Richard (BlackTuna) are incredible hosts!  Each week they dive into the Magic universe to discuss the various happenings across the galaxy.  I was able to hit Mythic playing MTG Arena a few months ago for the first time.  I was playing an Obosh deck before the companion nerf.  Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays if your crew celebrates?!  Best, Mogwai Bubbles #94642

Crim saves this podcast for me he funny do STOP SAYING THAT CRIM SHOULD NOT BE IN THE PODCAST

Appreciate that they don’t always agree with each other on topics and that they have different interests/play styles in the Magic world.

Imagine the most popular podcast of mtg. Now imagine a host that laughs and uses verbal pauses. Put that man thru a speech class. Thank you. Everyone else is great. Get rid of crim!!!!!!

I think they are very entertaining to listen to as a group! Keep it up, guys!

Not sure what he adds. He interjects and distracts from the flow Seth and Richard sets up. I feel the weird tension. Don’t mean to be harsh but there’s definitely not sure about Crim

I listened to two minutes of this podcast. I love the website, but I can’t stand these guys voices.

you guys are great and love your interactions greta job keep it up!

Decent podcast overall, but the hosts, particularly Richard, seem to be quite ignorant of formats outside of what’s on arena. Richard tends to be outright wrong in his perception of modern for example, and would be nice if Kess or Ben from the Masters of Modern podcast could come on periodically.

Seth is also mostly cool; although, he’s a bit too “Richard” at times. Richard, tho... You’re such a drag. Your whining is obnoxious. Do something else, for everyone’s sake. May you find some happiness.

Long time listener. Love hearing the crew’s opinions on the state of the game every week, and it’s nice to get the news if I didn’t have time to catch everything. I like hearing their takes on things. Of course I have my own opinions too, but they do a nice job breaking things down. Thanks guys!

If you wanna listen to Richard (the owner of MTGGoldfish) complain and cry about magic the gathering for an hour every week this is the place to get your fix. For some reason you can also hear him slapping his gums when he talks I thought I was the only one until I saw a review mention it also. Crim is always great to listen to and I used to love this podcast overall but I’m tired of all the complaining and whining that’s constant.

I was all in and enjoying this podcast until they started calling for and predicting the death of paper Magic. I know, it was only one person. Regardless, I am certainly not going to support this sort of “End of the World” fanaticism. See you guys. Good Luck.

I have gotten so much great information and entertainment from this great podcast! You guys are the best!

If you only listen to one MTG podcast this should be it. Super current and interesting. Stay up to date with three people that have a deep relationship with MTG.

If you are looking a nuanced look at the meta, and your a higher level player, not a good podcast for you. This is much more a podcast from the average joe perspective, which personally I enjoy because I don’t have the time or money for magic to be a serious hobby for me. They often talk about what they see on the internet, and if you frequently browse reddit and twitter, and watch out for magic news you won’t hear anything new. I personally want me news curated and don’t want to have to make an opinion for myself. To summarize, great for a casual player.

I appreciate having a good time or people making a good joke to laugh at but the hosts literally use laughter as communication mechanism because they can’t take themselves seriously. While I get that can be hard to get rid of that habit, it’s horrible to listen too when it’s over a third or half of the podcast.

I learn everything I need to know about Magic from this podcast, and helps me stay up to date on releases and changes

Seth, Crim and Richard keep up on MTG news, have good chemistry, and discuss a lot of things not found elsewhere in MTG podcasts. It's a weekly listen for me.

Crime has been an excellent addition to the show! Him and SaffronOlive make it worthwhile listening.

Dude Richard ya gotta learn to talk into the mic. You keep slapping your gums and lips when you talk? Idk what it is but it’s annoying. 5 stars for Saf

The discussion is good and better yet, really topical and consistent. However, the discussion will not help you win more and get an edge in competition because the hosts are either not playing (Richard) or medium at the game (Seth). Crim doesn’t really have the radio chops to add much to the podcast. Listen for fun, but don’t expect too much insight.

Crim seems like a great guy, but the mix of him with the two regulars is dramatically worse than it was with Chris Van Meter. CVM provided a nice serious counterbalance to the main hosts. But now it’s all cringey nervous laughter as everyone literally laughs at their own jokes... or even at no joke at all. “That card is good hahahaha.” What? I’d love the podcasters to treat the show a little more seriously instead of recording some buddies chatting with each other and calling it a day.

Can Crim complete a single sentence without chuckling? It’s actually distracting how often he laughs.