You guys started out a little rough, as any new crew would but now you’re both on point. Jay you’re awesome and so glad you’re so confident now compared to early episodes. You and Justin are equally great co-hosts, Justin you bring a great professional dynamic with your biologist background. Keep it up guys. I look forward to each episode.

Absolutely amazing show. Love listening on long shifts and road trips. Have you guys ever thought about prehistoric animals and their cryptid relatives. My theory is that the North American borophaginae evolved into our modern depictions of dog man. Since they have a bigger muzzle like a hyena and a lot of dog man sittings have hyena like heads. Much love Darth gator.

I love the whimsicality, enthusiasm, and consistency of this podcast! It makes for a very fun and engaging listen. Great work!

I liked the description of “cooking your head” in the shower to stop a migraine. lol You guys are great

Great podcast! Love these guys!

I just discovered Ur podcast this week…Gotta say I absolutely love it…I been trying to find a new Paranormal/Mystery Podcast to binge & U guys hit the mark…Loved all the Mothman Episodes & I’m so glad U didn’t condense them…wealth of info I’d never heard. Great job team…Also wanna add, it’s nice to have a quality Podcast that doesn’t feel the need for cussing.

I first saw you guys while watching Free The Rabbits "Trolls of the Ancient World" It was a good episode and I rewatched it to many times to count. Then you guys were back on Free The Rabbits for "Why Do Aliens Look So Much Like Us." Again, another good episode that I rewatched quite a bit. Finally, I decided to check you guys out. I've went back and listened to every episode & your documentaries. I've listened to a lot of episodes multiple times including the season finales. I usually put on a long episode when I'm going to sleep. Your content is so good, I can listen again and again. My 2 favorite episodes are the one on Megalania & Cryptoboteny: When Plants attack from S2... Awesome stuff guys, keep it up!!

Y’all are the business!!! O-H!!!

Love this podcast. Found them through Tony at the confessionals podcast. I have found Mr E and the J clones to be very entertaining and informative. Have learned so many things from the show. From crypids to everyday animals. I love the biology aspect of the show. Keep up the great work guys!

I find them very entertaining. I have learned a lot from listening to them.

I love listening to these guys. I love their set up where Mr. E reads then stops and ask Jay what he thinks so far or any questions. It’s like you’re hanging out with these and having a conversation. And I should know I have sat with these guys and had a conversation. Very knowledgeable.

These guys are really cool & cover all sorts of subjects in the universal realm of crytpid lore.

Listened to the dark watchers episode and almost became physically nauseated at the mispronunciations. It’s Bug Sur not Spur and Santa Loo-seee-uh not Santa Luka. Please do the work to pronounce words correctly.

I recently started listening to your show because the Apple algorithm thinks that this is a good place to go after an episode of Blurry Creatures or Ninjas are Butterflies. Its not wrong.

The show is okay. But it reminds me of a community college radio show. Local and amateurish. You guys have the potential to make a good, if not maybe great show. But you two are never on the same page. Mr E always talks over J Clone and in the moment during recording tells him why to do, IE “That’s good, save that for the end, I haven’t gotten to that yet!” This sort of gaffe happens repeatedly each episode and it’s really distracting. I almost didn’t write a review because you guys enjoy reading reviews just to make fun of the fanbase, the reviewers and anyone who decides they have an opinion that isn’t what you approve of. But I think that’s bullying and you guys need to listen occasionally and quit with the ego trip. [Updated ] 4/9/25 from 2/5 You guys have gotten it together and are both gelling on the same page. The show is awesome and me and the family love listening in every new episode. Good growth Justin and Jay. 5*’s

You guys are amazing, but now I can’t look up into the sky without thinking about what critters could be up there. 🤣 Keep up the good work! 🤩

This show has everything I look for in a podcast: good hosts who have good rapport, spooky content, frequent uploads, and plenty of tangents. Season finales are always an extra special treat. You guys are great. Keep up the good work.

Sounded like a great podcast reading all the different episode subjects.. sound quality ranges from subpar to decent.. feel like he says “sorry” too many times an episode and at awkward times.. last episode I could take it sounded like everyone sitting in a room on opposite sides and a central mic.. more annoying than interesting.. I tried..

Jay and Justin combine all the right pieces to make the show flow. The show has a standard flow and it works for every episode. They are great dudes and if you ever get to meet them they invite you in with open arms. I got to meet them at cryptidcon. My wife and I are big fans. Keep up the good work.

Y’all do a great job with this podcast !! I listen to everyone the confessionals, Sasquatch chronicles and cryptids of the corn !! Keep up the good work boys. I love how y’all cover real things in life and the possibilities of misidentification of extinct animals. You asked for a small town mystery. Have you heard of the witch of Yazoo. First grave I’ve ever seen that had chains all over it. They were to keep the “ witch “ from escaping her grave. Pretty wild and I’d love to hear the story behind it all. Thanks, Chris P.

Like the podcast!Heard you on the Confessional podcast so I thought I would check you out, glad I did:)

dudes. you guys are awesome. basically all i listen to anymore. i have 178 episodes DOWNLOADED on my iphone. yeah, it’s like that. thanks for all the awesomeness!!

I listen to the podcast everyday while I’m at work and I love it you guys are so informative but yet keep it entertaining I’ve listened to all of the freaky fauna Fridays and I love the D.W conspiracy shack you guys have made me want to buy my own land and raise my own animals and grow my own food you guys are amazing and I can’t wait to buy your book!! Keep up the great work I hope you guys and your families are doing great much love!

I have been listening to you guys ever since I found you from hillbilly horror stories and you are one of my favorite. I'm a huge monster movie guy so it's right up my alley. Both are very funny and kind and my kind of people. Would love some more creature feature kind of episodes! Thanks for making me laugh at work and help my days go by quickly!

This duo is fantastic, full of great information and fun to listen to. I love it when then get into the obscure crypids that rarely get covered.

Hardest working duo mucking it up in the corn delivering informative humorous and entertaining audio compendium of cryptid and alien knowledge worthy of supplementation in the United States of cryptids a tour of American myths and monsters. When not podcasting, you should definitely catch them at a festival. Gary

Can’t wait until you guys are doing this full time. I listen to every studio episode that doesn’t involve a guest, interview or review. You two are magic together. Keep up the great work!

EXCELLENT PODCAST!!! I used three exclamation points to illustrate your illustrious exuberance, I assure you it’s afar from asinine! Your shows will always have a protuberance in my heart, always listening and obfuscationally excited for season six!

Very Refreshing to hear the younger generation Thinking for themselves and using there God given gray matter.Thanks for all the great shows and I highly recommend this for the like minded.

I love learning about new cryptids!

I love the topics and the depth you go into them. I greatly enjoy the banter and off topic conversations it makes it feel natural and not like a scripted piece. Feels like I’m sitting with friends!

As a college student studying environmental science and microbiology I love the way these guys connect the supernatural with science. I’ve always love crypts and it’s cool to add new ones to my internal library. Keep up the good work!

These guys are 5-STAR Podcast Professionals. My favorite podcast by far for the subjects they cover. A pleasure to listen too. Great people doing a great thing. Please keep up the great work !!!

Justin and Jay are your number 1 destination for informative cryptid, paranormal, and urban legend entertainment! Love every episode. These guys dive deep into the mysterious legends and encounters with creatures hiding just on the edge of our known world, then discuss the biological possibilities of what these monsters might have been. For stories, science, and plenty of laughter, you have found the right place. Save this podcast, because you’ve just found your new favorite show!

Basically this show consists of one guy (Mr.E) carrying the entire show while the other guy (J-clone) chimes in every couple seconds with what some would find extremely annoying. It’s funny because from time to time you can sense how annoyed MrE is with J clone. Although this Jclone character contributes almost nothing if anything to every episode , by the end of each episode I almost end up feeling bad for him for the way MrE disagrees with almost every single thing he says when he actually tries to say something related to the topic at hand . Overall cool topics but the Mr E guy comes off as a know-it-all and a control freak about how and where the episode goes.

I love the stories and research they guys provide! Jay is my spirit animal!

These guys are so funny and informative. It’s like sitting in a room with friends chatting and BSing about science and the supernatural. Love these guys!

Talking for the sake of talking

Thanks you guys for recommending the fabulous garlic dust with a hint of sea salt by Flavors of The Forest!!! This stuff is totally amazing!! It’s so good if I could snort it, I probably would!! LOL Definitely 5+ stars you guys rock!!! Lesli D.

For the love and support!

Y’all are a great podcast. I enjoy the randomness and the intelligent information. Thank you

I do love the show and all aspects of it. I do wish that they would go a little more in depth with some of these sightings. Some of them are clearly fake and I feel they believe every single one are real lol. BUT other than that, I love the show. Intro is great, keep up the amazing work :)

Been loving this podcast for a while now. Started listening at the beginning of 23 and have listened every week since. All the information is educational and leaves you thinking “who knows, anything can be possible”. I was recently at the Columbus zoo looking at the hyenas with my wife. I leaned over and whispered “you know….the females have a fake penis, right?” The look she gave lol Let me help y’all’s algos. Paranormal paranormal paranormal paranormal cryptid cryptid cryptid mystery mystery mystery alien alien alien alien monster monster monster Cheers boys -Harrison V “dadbod_harrison”

Your guys are amazing a really intelligent show about clones In science and biology you guys are awesome

Terrible blah blah blah

Came over from Intothefraypod when Justin was a guest on. Great podcast! One of the episode happened not to far from where I live.

Wasted half of this episode listening to the actually story & they started talking about their own story & wasn’t even relevant to the actually story & on top of that it was their stories or experiences were BORING!! Some advice is to just stick to the story talk about it then talk about yours you guys tend to go off topic & shift gears & go somewhere else & then some of the times don’t even go back or I forgot crazy this is all took from this podcast after half of an episode. Disappointed. Listen go Blurry Creatures WAY better

Its 2019 miles between ape canyon and eureka ak

These guys get it!! A well crafted podcast around cryptids but that is just the beginning! It’s so so much more! And the banter between both Justin and Jay Clone (insert number) is fantastic and draws you into the serious topics with a slice of life! Having a former biologist aboard gives the show validity beyond what any of these other shows are doing these days! Also, the best hidden gem of the whole show is The Infamous Mr. Fungus which is strait up some of the best story telling I’ve ever heard with intricate breakdowns of who the Jay Clones are and how they were created! I can’t get enough of this show and y’all!!! #jayclonelove4life P.S. - tell Salma Hayek, I’m coming for her spot!!!!

A great podcast that I like to put on while I work. If someone happens to walk by while I have it playing, they eventually start asking me what I’m listening to and will stick around for a minute or two and have a listen.