I recently started getting into podcasts and this has became the only podcasts that I listen to. I tried other podcast out, but Believing the Bizarre is top tier! You guys have horror, comedy, conspiracy theories, etc. I LOVE your guy’s humor dude! I listen to you guys at work and while driving sometimes too! I went from listening to music at work to being excited to listen and catch up on all the podcast! THANK YOU! Hope to see you guys in person asap!

I listen to this alllll day at work. I’m a data entry accountant and this is in my headphones all day! I started listening to new episodes, currently I’m doing in order, starting from the beginning. I laugh out loud in my cubicle, I learn some new things, and I get to hear about all my favorite topics. I love the way these podcasts work, I love the delivery, makes it so fun and I stay engaged. Love it love it love it! Keep up the great work boys! From a Pittsburgh girl! 😝

I’m a longtime fan of paranormal podcasts and I usually listen to shows that just feature queer or female hosts, but I just found this podcast a couple of months ago. These guys having me cracking up every time I listen. I love the banter and I love that doesn’t get too off the rails. I get my paranormal fix and a good laugh.

An easy listen with laughs and fun stories — thank you for the work you do, lads!

Came for the aliens, stayed for the cryptids, ghosts, vampires, conspiracies, listener submissions and most of all these two incredibly funny and engaging personalities! Charlie and Tyler and hilariously entertaining hosts who also fill my fascination with all sorts of supernatural and extraterrestrial tales and encounters. Always excited to tune in every week, and even binge old episodes!

From Hatman to Cpt. Pup Pancake it’s been a great ride and I look forward to what is to come. Great chemistry gentleman….

I found you guys a couple of months ago. After a few episodes, I was hooked . I am still catching up and am listening almost daily . The banter between you guys literally has me lol . Keep making more episodes !!!

If you’re not hip you need to get a clue this is the podcast for you

Seriously.

I’ve been listening to this podcast for a couple of years now and it has become my absolute favorite! If you like spooky stuff and the paranormal, this is the pod for you! I don’t know when I started this review, but apparently never posted it! So here you go!

Came over from Spotify to write this 😜 - I love you guys, every episode is entertaining and full of laughs. Highly recommend to any and everyone, especially if you could use a good laugh!

That’s great!! These guys… they got something!

At first I was skeptical, I was not really interested in aliens and ghosts but the more I listened the more I fell into this trap of good episodes and fun stories

Love this podcast so much! The guys are funny and they always crack me up. Great stories too btw! I definitely recommend to all of my fellow humans.

if you want a show that is equally as scary as it is funny, this is the perfect podcast for you.

Great hosts and awesome show. Always listening to it at work.

Super well thought out and articulated discussions with everyday humor thrown in. Charlie and Tyler are amazing to listen to and cover so many awesome topics while also making heavy subjects feel lighter. 10/10 recommend to a friends

So the only Podcast I normally listen to is one podcast I’ve tried listening to others but didn’t really like the story , narrators voice , etc… but I’ve been tuned into this from 6:30-7:00 am & it’s currently 7:31 pm 😌 my anxiety has been so high this is the only thing keeping me calm 💙💙🫡

I absolutely love this podcast, I listen to it all the time. I see a lot of reviews on here talking about how they get sidetracked and make too many joke but I love it. It keeps it light hearted and helps me when it gets a little too scary as I spook easily lol. Never change 🩷

I’ve been listening to Tyler and Charlie nonstop for four days now at work (10 hours a day), and the ride home as well since stumbling across them trying to find an entertaining paranormal podcast. The content is engaging, there’s some good arguments and facts on all sorts of subjects, and if you’re anything like me, you’ll have more than a few embarrassing laugh-out-loud moments in public spaces because Charlie and Tyler have hilarious banter! I love their camaraderie, I can’t get enough of the mix of famous, obscure, and fan stories, and Tyler and Charlie each bring different information and sources to the table so there’s a fresh take each time. If you’re into any part of the paranormal, whether it be hauntings, UFOs and aliens, cryptids, demons and possessions, conspiracy theories, etc., definitely take a listen and be prepared to binge this podcast!

I have been searching for a podcast that doesn’t sound like a robot reading a narrative. I was specifically looking for a two person podcast where they can debate on things. I was also specifically looking for a podcast that covers multiple interesting topics including sci-fi, fiction, reality etc. I have been listening every single day and I started at episode 1. I just finished the OU episode and I can’t wait to hear what’s next. I love the comedy aspect as well, it definitely keeps things feeling light and realistic. Awesome podcast. LOVE LOVE LOVE

Absolute gem! Wandering through the forest of pods looking for my new addiction, when I come across this amazing show that makes me feel like I’m sitting around having a drink with a couple buddies. Great stories! Fun, funny, irreverent and informative! Do yourself a favor and don’t miss out on this!

You guys are hilarious!

Love, Love, Love the show! Love the guys!

Been listening to this podcast for about a month and this episode had me laughing by myself while plumbing love the show thanks guys🙏🏼

So Hi! I really love show and tend to listen to it a lot. It would be fun if you guys do another Japanese scary story like that one episode with the slit mouth lady and the toilet paper ghost!

I’ve been listening about 6-8 months, I’ve given 5 stars before but had to come back by to say I LOVED the alien abduction of betty a. recent episode! Like when I scroll past it I’m sad that I can’t listen to it for the first time again 🤣 do more alien episodes!! It was hands down one of my favorites! I also liked that it was a little longer than usual and so detailed. Bravo! 🤩

Yes, technically they occasionally tell stories on this podcast. But the hosts butcher the stories so badly with interruptions and jokes that they become hard to follow. I’m sure there’s an audience for it, but it’s not for me. Check out The Belief Hole for a much better version of this product

Just kidding. I really enjoy this pod cast and the banter. Ohio is my favorite accent.

Love y’all’s podcast! I listen to y’all’s story’s while I work, I’ll look down and 3 hours have passed by🤣 always make my work days fly by!

I absolutely love this podcast. These guys are so relaxing and real. I listen to this while I’m at work most days and it helps a lot with my sanity lol, now my biggest fear is running out of episodes. The listener story episodes are such a good touch between the more known stories, and I even got surprise memory flashbacks from the hatman mentions! Now I am watching the YouTube videos and it’s the perfect touch to my spooky gaming vibe! Hope you guys are having a good day, thanks for starting your podcast!

I just wanna say thank you for what you guys do you guys have really helped me just stay more active on my walking journeys. I listen to you guys when I need to go on a under one and don’t focus on the time so much and just keep moving before I know a good allotted time is gone by and I can feel accomplished. So thank you for that and I really like how there’s a vast variety of things to listen to. Haven’t listened to everything yet because you guys have been out for a while, but I usually take down a couple of day. ❤️💜

Keep your TDS out of it

We feel like y’all are kindred spirits! We love the research and banter, and would absolutely love a collaboration at some point! Keep at it y’all!

Best podcast ever! Never ever stop telling the stories!

Love the banter these two have but I’ll be honest, one of these guys sounds like Jonah Hill. It’s not a bad thing it just makes me chuckle.

This show has been my latest listening addiction for the last month or so. Whenever I’m doing chores or playing video games I am listening to episodes. The banter is at times hilarious and the stories are always interesting.

Awesome paranormal podcast with humor. Amazing guys with great personalities. Always looking forward to Tuesdays now. They are only podcast I actually keep up with.

I’ve listened to you guys for a while now, but I’ve fully made the switch from Spotify to Apple Music… so I thought I’d leave another review! You guys have the most entertaining conversations, and what I love about this podcast specifically is that you have such an open mind…. You take everything seriously and with so much respect, which is so refreshing. I also love that this podcast is a safe space for so many, especially in a world where the media (including so many podcasts) is being taken over and turned into alt-right propaganda machines.

I’ve always been interested in the paranormal and things that can’t be explained and this podcast provides me with a great collection of diverse content to dive into. As well as the confidence to open up about my own paranormal experiences! By far my favorite podcast I’ve listened to yet. I would highly recommend BTB!

Been listening to this show for a couple months now and it’s quickly became one of my favorite podcasts to listen to. If you love all things spooky you’ll love this podcast!

I listen to you guys on Spotify but since I can’t leave a review there I thought I’d leave one here. I found this podcast while looking for more stories about stairs in the woods a little while back, I’ve never been into paranormal before but found this very interesting and I’ve been listening to you guys ever since. I went back and started listening to Charlie and Tyler from the beginning and all the inside jokes and just good camaraderie is so fun. I’m thinking of joining their Patreon and am also thinking of submitting my own listener submission, I’m looking forward to being part of your fun community. Charlie and Tyler if your reading this hope you guys have a great day and Aw man that’s great -Hadley

It’s informative and funny. Charlie and Tyler seem like my friends now. Lolol thank guys!

Awesome just relaxing talks about the bizarre and just funny hanging around them. It feels like hanging around with your friends on a regular day. 💜

Love listening to these two the crack me up!! Very informative and honest! I love there banter!! Im so glad I heard of them through let’s get haunted and scared to death

Tyler and Charlie do such an amazing job with every episode and the Instagram page is fun to follow as well!

Love these guys. They know how to have a good time and bring the spooky

You guys literally rock! One of my new faves, so binging has ensued! Thanks for the humor, intelligence, info, and spooks.

Love this podcast. Charlie and Tyler bring a really fun and lighthearted approach to the unsettling topics of the paranormal. For those of us who love spooky stuff, but also scare easily and get anxiety if they overindulge, this podcast is the perfect medium. I also love how much they interact with their listeners 💛

I just started listening a few days ago, but I love the vibes and the content is top tier! Gonna be slowly working my way through the library here, but I’m already recommending y’all to friends and family!