The Giants’ offseason messaging is getting harder to decipher. Tyler Rogers heads to Toronto on one of the richest reliever deals of the winter, while San Francisco continues to float between big-name rumors and cost-conscious reality. We break down why the Giants were priced out on Rogers, what that means for the bullpen, and why Brendan Donovan remains a real trade target with Seattle and San Francisco emerging as frontrunners. Plus, mixed signals on Cody Bellinger, conflicting comments from ownership and the front office, and why national voices like Ken Rosenthal are openly confused about the Giants’ plan. We also dive into a major philosophical shift: baserunning. After ranking among MLB’s worst on the basepaths in 2025, Buster Posey and the coaching staff are betting that instincts, coaching, and selective aggression can unlock hidden value — even without elite speed. Is this a smart inefficiency play… or another sign the Giants are threading the needle instead of pushing all-in?